QCR Winter 2020: K Line Pte Ltd v Priminds Shipping (HK) Co Ltd (The “Eternal Bliss”) [2020] EWHC 2373 (Comm)

Are damages claimable in addition to demurrage following a delay in discharging?  Is a separate breach required?

K Line Pte Ltd v Priminds Shipping (HK) Co Ltd (The “Eternal Bliss”) [2020] EWHC 2373 (Comm)

The “Eternal Bliss” case arose from the carriage of a cargo of soybeans from Brazil to China under a voyage charterparty. There was a 31 day delay in discharging as a result of congestion, and a lack of storage space for the cargo. Upon inspection after discharge, the owner faced a cargo claim from the receivers in respect of alleged damage to the cargo. The owner settled the claim for in excess of US$1m, and then claimed this cost from the charterer. The breach that the owner alleged against the charterer was the failure to discharge the cargo within the laytime allowed under the charter. Consequently, the charterer said that the claim should be dismissed, on the basis that the demurrage regime provided an agreed, fixed monetary remedy for breach of this obligation. The question of law raised by the rival arguments was referred, on assumed facts, to the High Court in London.

For the full summary of this case, Members are directed to the UK Defence Club’s Soundings dated October 2020.

UK Club Staff

UK P&I

Date30/12/2020

Tags

You may also be interested in:

Articles

The preparation of cargo holds for the next intended carriage is a critical operation which requires careful planning and execution; this article considers a number of legal issues which may arise, including terms commonly used in charterparties to describe the cleanliness of cargo holds, the consequences of failing to comply with such terms, potentially resulting in off-hire claims and damages, and the role of the independent surveyor.

FAQ

Hold preparation is probably the most vital part of bulk carrier operations; if it is not undertaken properly, it can result in substantial cargo claims, delays, additional cleaning, survey costs and expensive off-hire disputes.

Videos

During the initial stages of the voyage, the vessel encountered heavy weather, with spray and seas shipped on deck and all hatch covers over a period of 8 days; this video explores how this affected the maize cargo.

Press releases

​In collaboration with I.M.E.Q., Sophia Bullard, Crew Health Director at UK P&I Club, discusses the issue of grief and its impact on crew, exploring the stages, signs and symptoms of grief, as well as coping mechanisms.