The views and opinions expressed here are solely those of the original author or contributor. These views and opinions do not necessarily represent those of the UK P&I Club.
Is it time for everyone to admit that global warming is upon us? If so, "Act of God" or Foreseeable risk?
The more frequent occurrences of natural disasters have certainly led to safety concerns by many ship owners. 2017 saw a trio of super-strong hurricanes flatten the Caribbean and US Gulf Coast, each storm causing tens of billions of dollars in damage. Similarly, earthquakes in Mexico and Iraq saw a combined loss of over 1000 lives and the worst floods in a decade poured over South Asia. For this reason it is natural to wonder if these disasters fall under the "Act of God" defence.
This is one of the exceptions available to a common carrier under the Hague/Hague-Visby Rules and English Law.
But in reality, is this defence still in existence.?
The English Law provides no clear definition - "Act of God" is historically literally construed. It is usually understood to be an inevitable accident caused by natural force and without human agency. There is no requirement for "foreseeability", but there has been no case record of a carrier attempting to reply on the "Act of God" defence in decades.
However, the matter gets more complicated under Chinese Law, where the "Act of God" defence is more frequently relied upon by the carrier.
"Act of God" is a defence available under the China Maritime code ("CMC"), which follows the doctrine of the Hague-Visby Rules, and governs all maritime matters. However, this defence is customarily treated in the same way as a Force Majeure event under the Chinese Contract Law, which only applies in the absence of express provisions under the CMC in a shipping dispute.
Under the Chinese Contract Law, the three characteristics of a Force Majeure event are unpredictability, inevitability and uncontrollability. Thus, when an "Act of God" defence is assessed under these criteria, it will be extremely difficult for a carrier to overcome the first hurdle: unpredictability. Given the accuracy of weather forecast these days, many natural phenomenon CAN be predicted.
It is no surprise then that the number of cases in China where a carrier successfully defends his case using the "Act of God" defence is minimal.
So what is our suggestion?
The carrier should expressly list out the exceptions (for example, typhoon, flood etc.) to form his own defence, in order to avoid being caught by the definition of Force Majeure under Chinese Law.
In other words.do not just leave it in God's hands!
You may also be interested in:
A Roadmap for Ship Decarbonisation
Global warming is one of the most severe and complex challenges our world faces today; there is an urgent need to reduce emission levels and avoid the most devastating impacts of climate change and every individual, business, and industry, including shipping, has a part to play.
Press Release: UK Club builds on strength of regional offices with two appointments in Greece and Hong Kong
The UK P&I Club, one of the leading providers of P&I insurance and other services to the international shipping community, has announced Seán Geraghty will become the new Regional Director in its Greek office in November, while Daniel Evans will move from Greece to London to focus on the continued development of the UK Defence Club.
MPA Singapore Port Marine Circular No.19
The Maritime and Port Authority (MPA) of Singapore recently issued Port Marine Circular No.19 of 2022 which introduced a requirement for all non-vaccinated crew arriving in Singapore after 28th August to perform a pre-departure COVID test 2 days before arrival and hold valid travel insurance which covers them for all COVID risks.
Circular 09/22: EU Sanctions - clarification published on the carriage of certain Russian cargoes including coal and fertilisers
On 19 September 2022 the EU further amended its FAQS clarifying the application of provisions relating to the carriage of certain cargoes from Russia, including coal and other solid fossil fuels as well as certain types of fertilizer.