Skip to content
Emma Hearn
Emma Hearn
Date
20 November 2026

Members employing Filipino seafarers should be aware of a recent ruling by the Supreme Court of the Philippines concerning certain provisions of the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers, including the execution of monetary awards and restrictions on legal fees. The Court has declared parts of Sections 59 and 60 unconstitutional, while confirming that the remainder of the Magna Carta remains valid and enforceable.

Background

The Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers (Republic Act No. 12021) was signed into law on 23 September 2024 and came into effect on 11 October 2024.

The legislation was introduced to strengthen and codify the rights and responsibilities of Filipino seafarers and to align domestic legislation with international maritime standards.

For Members, the legislation also sought to address some longstanding issues associated with Filipino crew claims. Of particular importance were provisions dealing with garnishment (the execution of disputed disability and death awards while appeals remained pending) (Section 59), together with measures intended to address ambulance chasing lawyers and legal fees charged to seafarers (Section 60).

The Supreme Court ruling

On 11 November 2026, the Supreme Court issued an important ruling on several challenges to the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers, finding that certain provisions of the law and its implementing rules were unconstitutional or invalid.

Section 59: Execution of monetary awards

Section 59 was introduced to deal with the payment of monetary awards while a claim was still under appeal. Undisputed amounts could be paid immediately, but a seafarer wishing to enforce a disputed award had to provide a bond to ensure the money could be recovered if the award was later overturned or reduced.

The Supreme Court has now ruled that this bond requirement is unconstitutional, finding that it placed an unfair financial burden on seafarers that did not apply to other workers.

The Court also struck down related provisions concerning the use of the Department of Migrant Workers’ AKSYON Fund to pay bond premiums and the rules implementing the bond requirement.

The Court also found that part of the Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) governing the application of Section 59 was invalid because it conflicted with existing protections for Filipino seafarers under the Magna Carta.

Section 60: Legal fees and representation

Section 60 introduced measures intended to protect seafarers from excessive legal fees and abusive practices, including a 10% cap on legal fees. The Supreme Court ruled these provisions unconstitutional, finding that the regulation of lawyers and the practice of law falls within the Courts authority.

What remains of the Magna Carta?

The Supreme Court did not invalidate the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers as a whole.

Challenges to Sections 75, 76 and 78 concerning maritime education and training were rejected. The Court also rejected challenges to the legislative process by which Republic Act No. 12021 was enacted and confirmed its procedural validity.

However, Section 59 was a key provision to Members with Filipino crew as it enabled Members to handle crew claims without the fear of garnishment. 

What does this mean for Members?

For Members, the most significant impact relates to disputed crew claims.

The removal of the Section 59 bond requirement means that a disputed monetary award may be enforced while an appeal is ongoing without the security previously required for repayment if the award is later overturned. In practice, this may mean that a seafarer can execute an award before the Court of Appeal is able to rule on the case.   

The ruling also affects the controls imposed by Section 60 concerning legal fees and representation, reducing one of the measures intended to discourage ambulance chasing lawyers and excessive legal charges in crew claims. This will have an impact on the seafarers themselves, rather than their employers.   

Members handling affected claims should therefore be aware of the judgment and seek advice from the Club and local correspondents on individual cases, particularly where enforcement of an award is contemplated while an appeal remains outstanding.

Next steps

The Decision is not yet final. The State, through the Office of the Solicitor General, has 15 days from receipt of the Decision to file a Motion for Reconsideration to challenge. 

As regards the affected Sections of the Magna Carta, we will have to see if they can be re-drafted in a way that will be accepted by the Supreme Court. 

The Club will continue to monitor developments and provide further updates as appropriate.

 

Official case briefer issued by the Supreme Court attached.