Lessons Learnt: Wash damage due to excessive speed

missing-image
Vessel Type: Tanker

Incident description

This partly laden tanker was proceeding inbound along a narrow river channel with a pilot on board. The transit was taking place in the early morning hours on a flood tide. Shortly before entering a stretch of the channel with occupied river berths, the pilot ordered the vessel's speed to be reduced from full ahead to half ahead. After passing the berths, the speed was again increased to full ahead. Later that day, the tanker's Master received notice that his vessel was alleged to have caused wash damage to a bulk carrier alongside one of the river berths due to proceeding at excessive speed. The damage included the destruction of the accommodation ladder and the parting of a number of mooring ropes due to the bulk carrier ranging forward and aft when the tanker was passing.

Analysis

It was determined that the tanker's speed at the time of passing the berths was about 9.5 knots whereas port regulations imposed a speed limit of 7 knots in this stretch of the river. Although the tanker was proceeding along the middle of the channel, its relative narrowness meant that vessels alongside the river berths could potentially be affected by the wash of other vessels passing at excessive speed. The engine revolutions could have been reduced earlier to comply with the regulatory speed limit thus lessening the wave disturbance generated by the vessel's movement. Although the pilot stated concern that a lower speed could adversely affect manoeuvrability as the vessel was trimming by the head due to squat, the effect of such interaction with the ground would decline with a reduction in speed.

Lessons Learnt
  • Passage planning in confined waters should take into account both safe speed and compliance with regulatory speed limits. The speed of the vessel should be closely monitored and adjusted as required.
  • Areas where speed limits are critical should be identified and discussed during the Master/Pilot information exchange.
  • Good bridge resource management would require any potential non-compliance with speed limits to be brought to the attention of the master and/or pilot.
  • Necessary reductions in speed should be made gradually and in good time as circumstances allow.
  • Master, officers and pilots should be fully aware of the effects of interaction on draft, manoeuvrability and wave generation in restricted waters.
  • Vessels berthed alongside river/channel berths should ensure that moorings are frequently tended and not allowed to become slack.
The UK Club's Loss Prevention team combines practical solutions that address Members' needs and claims experience with research into the wider issues that impact directly on P&I insurance and the Club's exposure to claims. Every year, the UK P&I Club deals with thousands of claims using the expertise and experience of its professional claims handlers, ex-seafarers and lawyers. With five decades of research into loss prevention issues the Club has developed a formidable body of technical material on maritime risks. Each month the Loss Prevention team aim to share some of the Club's claims experience, by looking at real case examples and identifying lessons learnt to help Members avoid similar incidents - you can find past lessons learnt here: https://www.ukpandi.com/loss-prevention/training-advice/lessons-learnt/

Staff Author

UK P&I

Date04/10/2017

Tags

You may also be interested in:

The UK P&I Club received the following update from Harpaz P&I, a local Israeli correspondent, regarding the port situation in Israel. 

In this article, the Club provides an overview of the emerging technology of shipboard carbon capture highlighting pros and cons where appropriate.

Founded in 1543, Santos has been long known as a port city – first through the export of coffee and then other commodities. Santos was significantly modernised and expanded in the 1990s to incorporate new technologies, operating with specialised terminals for containers, general cargo, and dry and liquid bulk, and it is responsible for almost 27% of the country’s trade. Santos is considered the largest port in Latin America, with its docks being 25 km long and able to accommodate about 50 ships at a time.   

The Persian Gulf, Hormuz Strait, and Oman Sea continue to remain one of the most challenging regions in terms of maritime security, with a wide variety of threats to vessels operating in the area.