Tsakos and UK P&I Club gain victory for shipowners in the US Supreme Court.

On Monday 30th March 2020, the United States Supreme Court found in favour of the Owner of a Tsakos managed ship, when the court held that the safe port clause in the industry’s ASBATANKVOY form constitutes a warranty of safety, in long standing litigation funded by the UK P&I Club in response to an accident involving the tanker ATHOS I in the Delaware River on 26 November 2004. In consequence of Monday’s court decision, damages in the sum of approximately $75 million will be reimbursed by the voyage charterer, CITGO, and shared between the ship’s owner, the UK Club, and benefitting the International Group’s Pooling system and Reinsuring Underwriters.

The court decision brings US law into alignment with the long standing position in English law, namely that this clause represents a warranty of safety to call at the load and/or discharge port nominated by the charterer. Following the expenditure of costs incurred in response to this pollution related accident, the total recovery due to the UK Club, on its own behalf and for the IG Pool and Reinsuring Underwriters, is estimated to reach a record breaking sum of $160 million.    

The many years of effort, which have culminated in the above decision,  underscore our confidence in the rule of law while  the Supreme Court’s decision underlines the importance and significance of safe, well respected, understood and applied marine navigation practices, which have, for decades, safeguarded human life at sea, the protection and preservation of the marine environment as well as property. 

At this time of unprecedented global challenges to health and welfare of humanity, it is wholly proper and appropriate once again to thank the many men and women  of the US Coast Guard and other governmental agencies, private contractors and individual workers as well as the Master, Officers  and crew of the Tsakos-managed tanker, who, from the very beginning of the incident, participated and contributed efficiently and effectively to the cleaning up operation from the spilled oil, whilst safeguarding the safety of all involved in the operation to protect and preserve the local environment. The aftermath to the ATHOS I incident highlights the constructive professional cooperation demonstrated by the privately owned shipping industry, the ship’s liability insurer - the UK P&I Club, and federal government services at the highest level with a beneficial outcome for the community and the environment.

A copy of the press release is available in full here.

Staff Author

UK P&I

Date01/04/2020

Tags

You may also be interested in:

Quarterly Case Review

Equitable Compensation for Failure to Comply with Arbitration Clause; the Owners issued bills of lading (governed by English law) for the cargo which contained a law and jurisdiction clause providing that disputes arising under the bills of lading were to be determined in arbitration in London.

Press releases

​UK P&I Club launches Lessons Learnt video on failure to conduct adequate cargo checks.

Quarterly Case Review

The Crossing and Narrow Channel Rules; the Supreme Court has, for the first time in nearly 50 years, provided clarification on the construction of the International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea 1972, as amended (“the Collision Regulations”) for the purposes of applying the Crossing Rules (Rules 15-17).

Articles

Following the collision in the deep water channel of Changjiangkou (CJK) area, Shanghai Maritime Administration (the “Shanghai MSA”) has issued a Safety Notice to urge all ships to undertake thorough propulsion and auxiliary machinery detection prior to departure from the berth or arrival in the restricted waters.