Letters of Indemnity - Alert! - Are you being asked to break the law!?
The views and opinions expressed here are solely those of the original author or contributor. These views and opinions do not necessarily represent those of the UK P&I Club.
"A Member approached the Club asking for our help to pursue a claim under a Letter of Indemnity (LOI) issued by a charterer / shipper.
LOIs are used all the time - even when, perhaps, they shouldn't be. Traditionally, there are two parts to an LOI: i) the promise to pay or cover the losses of (i.e., indemnify) the other party; and, ii) an event which, if it occurs, activates the indemnity. They help fill the gaps in the long and formal contracts. They are mini-contracts, if you like, which make business more ... fluid.
For example, where bills of lading are not available at the discharge port, charterers / shippers issue an LOI to owners, promising to indemnify him for any losses suffered from releasing cargo without presentation of the bills. Another example would be where charterers / shippers need clean bills of lading when they should be claused.
But are LOIs all what they are cracked up to be? It is worth bearing in mind that LOIs are not always enforceable, which means that your LOI may not even be worth the paper it is written on ...
Under English law, parties can do and contract to whatever takes their fancy, unless the substance of that contract is prohibited by law. The key bit of that sentence, however, is unless ... prohibited by law. For example, you cannot contractually agree to commit a crime. Any such contract would be ignored by any lawyer or judge - it would be entirely unenforceable, regardless of what payments had been made under it.
Some of the situations in which LOIs are commonly issued are actually an agreement to break the law and, therefore, entirely unenforceable. One of those situations is even given above - do you recognise it? Yes - it is the LOI issued in respect of issuing clean bills. Charterers promised an indemnity in exchange for issuing clean bills, despite knowing that there was damage to the cargo.
When signing the bills, the Master is representing to the receiver that the cargo corresponds with the description given. If the Master knows that description to be incorrect but still issues it, then he has knowingly made a misrepresentation to the receiver. Effectively, he has committed a fraud. Fraud is, of course, a crime. So that LOI cannot actually be enforced. The indemnity provider is free to walk away without any fear of a recourse action from owners.
So, unfortunately, because the master knew the cargo was not as described on the bill, that Member's LOI was entirely unenforceable and their P&I cover was prejudiced. The Member was left holding the full claim from the defrauded receiver who unexpectedly received damaged cargo with no recourse. They had to rely on commercial pressures to persuade charterers to respond, and even that was not particularly successful.
Always think about what you are being asked to do ... and why. This issue can be buried in fancy wordings, heated debates or justifications of urgent action. If you have any doubts, then feel free to get in touch - that is what we are here for!"
You may also be interested in:
Request from the Turkish Authorities for Confirmatory Letters of P&I Cover for Ships Entering International Straits and Turkish Waters, Ports and Terminals
Members will be aware that the Government of Turkey issued a notice dated 16.11.2022 which requires oil tankers transiting or entering Turkish waters from 01 December 2022 (extended to 02 December 2022), to provide letters of confirmation from the owner’s P&I Club attesting that cover will remain in place under any circumstances throughout the duration of the transit or the time the ship is in Turkish waters or the time it is in a Turkish port or terminal.
The UK P&I Club, one of the leading providers of P&I insurance and other services to the international shipping community, has announced that Amy Lovseth will assume the role of Syndicate Manager in its Hong Kong office following Sean Geraghty's move to the Greece office earlier this autumn.
The Latest Developments in Limitation of Liability under Greek Law: Losing the Right to Limit Liability
The international legal framework relating to the entitlement of shipowners to limit their liability for maritime claims has been established by the entry into force of the 1976 Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims
In this article, we look at why depression and anxiety in men so often go undetected and unrecognised, especially in male-dominated environments such as seafaring, and what can be done to address this issue.